This is a much overdue review of a pair of Leki Makalu Carbonlite walking poles, supplied to me back in June(??!) by Webtogs. Suffice to say I've had plenty of opportunity to try them out and abuse them, both in the UK and in Norway, so here are my thoughts for you, should you have some spare cash after Christmas...
First of all, product description. On first impressions they look great! In a black lacquered finish with a carbon 'look' to them they have silver and gold branding which makes them look a bit special. Made of carbon they are strong and really lightweight for a mainstream brand, weighing in at 391g in total for both poles combined (weighed this morning and including a token bit of dirt...). In three sections, they extend from 66cm to 135cm which makes them a great option for use with a shelter (I used them with my Shangri-La 1 and my Trail Star) and the twist action super lock system means they're easily adjustable when you've put the poles in situ.
However, the primary purpose of walking poles is, of course, to aid walking. Comparing these carbon Makalus with the old aluminium anti shock Makalus I previously used, the difference in weight was astounding! It made a massive difference walking using lighter poles. Lighter poles just mean that using them feels effortless; although I hadn't really noticed any effort with the old ones, these lighter ones really brought the weight of the old ones into relief.

These Carbonlite Makalus have a carbide flex tip, come with a basket fitment (which I usually leave attached) and have a curious Aergon handle which reminded me of a shark's head, a little different to the usual upright cork or moulded forms but which actually were really comfortable. The only comment I would have with these, which could equally apply with Pacer Poles, is that the shape of the head means that using with a shelter slightly distorts the pitch line, but this is very minimal and you would have to be really picky to take issue with this point. I'm not so picky and haven't really found it to be an issue that can't be dealt with by simply turning the head around to match the angle.
There is also a 'Safety Strap' which I find assists in walking (depending on your style; they can give more leverage), but which I've also heard general reports of people breaking wrists when using. That is a general comment about poles though, rather than part of this specific review, but I will say that I did find that the material rubbed my hands which surprised me; I think the stitching on the straps attaching the Leki branding caused this so that will be unpicked!
One of the main features of this pole, apart from the light weight, is the Super Lock System which proffers a holding force of up to 140kg, or 309 lbs in old money. The poles use a twisting action to secure the length, which I didn't, to be totally honest, find totally reliable. On occasion I found that the poles undid themselves and after a while I found I would almost automatically detect when they'd undo and would re-twist them back into position. While there was the minor annoyance factor I am a little concerned that they could let you down when you really needed that support. They also stuck once when out walking but after a few minutes wrestling to take them apart and reassemble they resumed normal functionality. However in researching others' findings with these poles I didn't find any similar issues so wonder if it's just a spurious issue with the ones I have.
Overall I found these poles to be a great addition to my walking kit and even with the niggles I mention above, I would still recommend these if you are looking for a light weight pole from a well established mainstream manufacturer.
These poles can be bought online from Webtogs at £116.99; a 10% saving on the RRP, with a one year limited guarantee against shaft breakage and Webtogs' usual outstanding delivery, customer service and price match promise.
First of all, product description. On first impressions they look great! In a black lacquered finish with a carbon 'look' to them they have silver and gold branding which makes them look a bit special. Made of carbon they are strong and really lightweight for a mainstream brand, weighing in at 391g in total for both poles combined (weighed this morning and including a token bit of dirt...). In three sections, they extend from 66cm to 135cm which makes them a great option for use with a shelter (I used them with my Shangri-La 1 and my Trail Star) and the twist action super lock system means they're easily adjustable when you've put the poles in situ.However, the primary purpose of walking poles is, of course, to aid walking. Comparing these carbon Makalus with the old aluminium anti shock Makalus I previously used, the difference in weight was astounding! It made a massive difference walking using lighter poles. Lighter poles just mean that using them feels effortless; although I hadn't really noticed any effort with the old ones, these lighter ones really brought the weight of the old ones into relief.

These Carbonlite Makalus have a carbide flex tip, come with a basket fitment (which I usually leave attached) and have a curious Aergon handle which reminded me of a shark's head, a little different to the usual upright cork or moulded forms but which actually were really comfortable. The only comment I would have with these, which could equally apply with Pacer Poles, is that the shape of the head means that using with a shelter slightly distorts the pitch line, but this is very minimal and you would have to be really picky to take issue with this point. I'm not so picky and haven't really found it to be an issue that can't be dealt with by simply turning the head around to match the angle.
There is also a 'Safety Strap' which I find assists in walking (depending on your style; they can give more leverage), but which I've also heard general reports of people breaking wrists when using. That is a general comment about poles though, rather than part of this specific review, but I will say that I did find that the material rubbed my hands which surprised me; I think the stitching on the straps attaching the Leki branding caused this so that will be unpicked!
One of the main features of this pole, apart from the light weight, is the Super Lock System which proffers a holding force of up to 140kg, or 309 lbs in old money. The poles use a twisting action to secure the length, which I didn't, to be totally honest, find totally reliable. On occasion I found that the poles undid themselves and after a while I found I would almost automatically detect when they'd undo and would re-twist them back into position. While there was the minor annoyance factor I am a little concerned that they could let you down when you really needed that support. They also stuck once when out walking but after a few minutes wrestling to take them apart and reassemble they resumed normal functionality. However in researching others' findings with these poles I didn't find any similar issues so wonder if it's just a spurious issue with the ones I have.Overall I found these poles to be a great addition to my walking kit and even with the niggles I mention above, I would still recommend these if you are looking for a light weight pole from a well established mainstream manufacturer.
These poles can be bought online from Webtogs at £116.99; a 10% saving on the RRP, with a one year limited guarantee against shaft breakage and Webtogs' usual outstanding delivery, customer service and price match promise.
My Aluminium Fizan Compact poles weigh 335g and cost < £50.
ReplyDeleteNo durability issues so far, I'm 100kg/188cmJust sayin';)
Sweet! I'm glad you posted that up because presenting options to other non experts like me, who might happen across this blog, is what it's all about!
ReplyDeleteWhere are the drawings we did? :). Too bad they wore away. Anyway, they looked like nice poles when we went hiking this summer.
ReplyDeleteFrasier: I had a pair of those Fizan Compact this summer, but ended up making my own pacer poles from them when I slipped ;).
Helen, nice to see you back blogging: don't leave it so long next time (unless you're out doing something more enjoyable of course, in which case who wants to be sat at a keyboard?).
ReplyDeleteAre the new poles sprung (anti-shock)?
Happy new year.
Nice write up! You'd think the main thing a manufacturer would build into a trekking pole is a locking mechanism that doesn't conk out wouldn't you?! Those Leki's look great, but that twist/lock system sounds a bit dodgy! My old Exped ones also unlocked now and again when I least expected it. Pretty frustrating, but I'm thinking it's partially my fault for being brutal on gear :) I'm so happy with my Black Diamond poles, but it's always nice to read about other products. Keep the posts coming :)
ReplyDeleteHehe! The photos were taken before that particular abuse was administered to the poles ;)
ReplyDeleteCheers! I have some thoughts on what I want to blog about, but haven't really felt like doing much lately - other things on my mind ;)
ReplyDeleteThe poles aren't anti shock. My previous pair were but I didn't really find much benefit in that, plus when used as shelter support and the wind got up I'd be kept awake by the 'boinging'!
Godt nyttår!
Thanks Greg! I did do some research before I wrote my thoughts up, just to see if it was a common problem, but I can honestly say I didn't find another occurrence of this issue. Maybe it was a one off?
ReplyDeleteSeeing alternative locking mechanisms, including that on the BDs, is interesting to compare. Thanks for your comment!
Great to see you blogging again!
ReplyDeleteThanks Andrew! I hope your new site is successful!
ReplyDeleteThanks Andrew! I hope your new site is successful!
ReplyDeleteI have the Makaklu poles (non carbon) and I find that the extending parts donot always open freely. These are replacements by Leki as the originals also stuck. I am wary now because if the play up I may have trouble with my Shangri La 1. If I have to buy again I will look closely at the locking systems which are external.
ReplyDeleteGood to have you back on line
Thanks Bob. I'm sorry to hear you've had issues with your Lekis too. I had a pair of Lekis before these and never really had issue, one saved me from what could have been a very nasty fall and I'm thankful to say only bent slightly. But yes, when you rely on them for use with a shelter you need that reassurance, otherwise you will be stuck!
ReplyDeleteI have both the Leki Carbonlite and Fizan Everest ones. I use both depending on the terrain. I like both of them and have not really had any issue.
ReplyDelete