Friday, 4 March 2011

Torridon - The Kit

A couple of people have asked me what kit I took with me on the trip to Torridon, well, what kit I use generally, so I'm giving a separate entry for this alone. Please bear in mind that:
1. The kit I used has been pieced together in a largely evolutionary process which has not reached fully evolved status and is a work in progress. Other people have a 'better' kit set up than me so I am not representing this list as a guide, just a baseline of where I'm at at present.
2. This work in progress is progressing very slowly as any surplus cash I have is generated from selling 'stuff' on ebay and which tends to be spent on petrol for trips rather than updating my kit. Suggestions for improvement are welcome, but please be mindful of a very limited budget to be able to respond; I would rather get out in the hills than buy new kit!
I have also made some notes as to how I use some of the items; it's been useful as I write the list up to reflect how I could be more efficient, and again if there are other ways you have that you think could be useful please add your thoughts!

Shelter
The shelter I used was an MLD Trailstar, which I've used a number of times now. It's a great, lightweight shelter although I need to re-do the seam sealant after TheNewNomads was dripped on a couple of times overnight. It weighs 470g including the 2mm Dyneema guys and line loks. I could trim down the guy lines as I've never needed the length currently on them. I currently store it in a not very efficient Outdoor Designs Silnylon Ultralite sack which weighs 16g.
The pegs I use with it are a mix of pegs from my old Trisar, at 17g each, and some Akto pegs at 11g each, totalling for this trip at 128g. I store them in a thickish plastic bag which weighs 3g. I got some lighter pegs for Christmas so will use those on the next outing.
The shelter doesn't have a groundsheet with it, just being a skin in effect, and because I had left my polycryo bundled up (and now slightly green and smelly) after my last outing, I used a rather heavy silnylon groundsheet I have which weighs 342g in a mesh stuffsack. (I don't normally use this groundsheet.) It wasn't big enough to cater for more than one person so Kim brought a separate sheet. That totals 956g without Kim's sheet.

Generally I like my shelter set up though obviously there are areas I could make a lot of saving (the polycryo groundsheet instead for example though I find it to be a pain to fold up and pack, and it wears out quickly so will replace with a lighter silnylon sheet I think). But my main concerns are the size of the thing where pitch space is tight, and in full on winter weather with bowling winds of rain or snow I would say you have to expect some ingress, despite the ability to pitch low. Even on the top of a hill with a double skin tent you are going to get spindrift inside the fly if the weather is that way so expecting better performance from a single skin shelter would be I suggest illogical. We had some weather in from the front opening so this is my experience.
For the future I am thinking tents again, maybe something like the GoLite Shangri-La 1 or 2, though I love my basic tarp and am looking to do a lot more of that this year. I will certainly look to get a bug net for the Trailstar for the midge season. For winter I am drawn to the Vaude Power Lizard or even the old Akto or TN Laser Competition.

Sleeping
The lightweight crowd may groan at this but for this trip I took a heavy Snugpack Softie Elite 3, a military spec bag, weighing 1685g inc stuffsack. Swapping out the stuffsack for a lighter compression bag would reduce the weight some, and I could change the zip pulls etc. But I like the bag a lot, it's olive green which I strangely love, it's got a great lined feet area for hardcore bivvying with boots on (not that I'll probably ever do this) and I like the shoulder and hood baffles. A great thing was that in the morning when I discovered my feet were venturing for freedom outside of the shelter, a bit of a flick of the bag and a quick wipe with a bit of pack towel and the bag was fine. Amazing considering how wet the weather had been through the night.
It's a 3 season bag which I lined with a Sea to Summit Thermolite Reactor Extreme liner, which I like the feel of and which seemed to help boost the rating of the bag. It weight a whopping 414g; yes, the weight made me gulp too. It was above freezing though I suspect not by too much overnight on the Torridon trip. I was warm enough but did have my clothes on too! I do sleep horrendously cold though which is incredibly annoying because it means I have to boost whatever bag arrangements I have which of course means more weight, and more cash.
A great asset was borrowing a POE Bamboo sleeping mat (610g) which I've had a bit of trouble finding a link for so I suspect it's not for sale now, but I've never tried a mat with insulation in it before and it was a revelation for me. Definitely something on my wish list for next winter.
I don't bother with a pillow when sleeping but was incredibly impressed with Kim's Big Agnes Clear View pillow, so very light. I may add that to my list (it's always so interesting walking and camping with others to see what they have and how they use it; I always learn something new).

Thinking into the future, for cold weather I would really love to be able to afford a 4/5 season bag and to take fewer clothes and possibly not take the liner, but the low cash flow I've had this year has meant a lot of compromise. For summer I have the option of using this liner with a bivy bag for sleeping outside, but I do like using quilts instead so would like to get something better than the Thermarest Down quilt that I currently have (which may in the future be subjected to a MYOG makeover...). A lot is driven by cost; if I spend money on this then I have less to spend to get to the Lakes or further away and I would rather get out there! I tend to spend in smaller increments to 'patch up' kit I have, but I do recognise that saving for some bigger items would give me different benefits. Hmm, food for thought. It would mean I wouldn't be able to get away as often as I have managed to do...


Pack
I use a GoLite Jam original version (since replaced with Jam 2) that weighs 560g. I used it first on my West Highland Way walk back in August last year and it's been with me on every overnight plus walk since. I like the pack a lot, though would love a better front pocket and pack compression straps to really cinch it down when it empties. Hip belt pockets would be really lovely too, though I don't miss padding at all (maybe that's because I have plenty myself!). Most of all I really miss having a top pocket. I used to find it so useful for segregating my stuff, and I felt more secure against rain finding its way, rather than through the roll top that's on this pack. It, like me, tends to have a bit of a pear shape thing going on, where I prefer a more structured pack.
I did try on an Osprey Exos 46 which felt absolutely fantastic with about 10Kgs of shop weight loaded into it (I know you could probably argue this with most packs), but I'm not sure I could put a use to all the straps and 'features' that abound. I have an Osprey Hornet 24 on loan which I'm trying out so will report on that at some point soon too, though my kit wouldn't squeeze down that much for an overnighter with it.

For packing I use a mix of sea to sumit and exped dry sacs but am seriously thinking of getting a big sea to summit pack liner and doing away with some of the other bags. There is an advantage though in that they keep your kit organised, though conversely I find I get a better pack shape if I stuff extraneous, loose stuff in it.
Thinking to the future I would like to replace it, even one day with a mighty Laufbursche huckePACK, a Colin Ibbotson (or should I call it Tramplite?) Skins pack, but if I could find a supplier in the UK for an Osprey Hornet 46 I would seriously consider that, or even an OMM pack...

So, so far the weight is at 4225g...

Cooking
Once again I took my bea-yoo-tiful Caldera Cone (34g, plus plastic caddy 73g), with my MSR Titan Kettle (90g)  but this time took a Gram Cracker (3g) with Esbit tablets (14g each). I do like the proper foil sealed Esbit tablets rather than the Hexamine tablets you get with Highlander Hexi stoves though I find them hard to obtain. I used a heavy, blow torch like Turboflame Multi Task lighter (76g) to light the Esbit which did take after some gentle persuasion. I had a basic bic lighter and a few waterproof matches too; at one point all combinations were used it was that damp!  I also took an MSR Titanium Mug at 60g which was useful for coffee while I was using the pot; no I don't have a Kuksa...


Food wise I described it in my post but I am really proud of myself, that I prepared a bolognese sauce and dehydrated it at home before trying it for the first time here. That and eating proper ramen noodles (Blue Dragon, 4 bundles in a pack weighing 250g, one bundle is a large portion for a meal but they hydrate really quickly; £1.07 from Asda) made me feel like a 'real' backpacker!

The bolognese was stored in a normal supermarket freezer zip type bag but divided up into a Pour and Store bag I'd got from Morrisons and the food reheated in that (4 for £1 if memory serves correct). They have a gussetted bottom which means they can stand up if you have somewhere flat to put them. I opted for the cradling in my hands option to warm up and 'manipulate' my food to encourage it to hydrate. (No idea if that worked but my hands were toasty on the inside at least!). I added the ramen noodles to the Pour and store bag when they'd cooked, including the v small amount of water left from boiling in a tribute to Ray J, and ate (scooped) from the bag with my Spork (10g).

On the walk itself I think I had a snickers bar and I usually take a bag with a handful or two of GORP, literally raisins and peanuts in this case, with the addition of a couple of brasils and walnuts.
Other than that it was porridge for breakfast (a mix of Oat So Simple original with a handful of fat steel cut rolled oats) made with water that I'd boiled for coffee. A slightly squashed banana was consumed to avoid further squashing in the pack (messy).

For water; water was plentiful! And there was no need to filter it either as it was running straight off the hillside, especially the following morning. So I had my 600ml Tango bottle (28g) as my main receptable - which I also drink directly from - and my 2l Platypus (47g) which I just used at camp to collect water. It has a narrow opening and collecting the water from the burn (from the loch so maybe it could have been contaminated, though low risk) was very, very cold. I could barely feel my fingers at the half full mark. I would have been better off using the MSR Kettle to collect water to pour into the platy instead.

Clothing
As usual I had my black Icebreaker Bodyfit200 long sleeved top, a dark heather coloured Berghaus Spectrum Micro Full Zip Fleece and my black Mountain Equipment Seraph jacket which was worn AT ALL TIMES!
This was coupled with a pair of black Craghoppers Kiwi Stretch Pants (I must write about these; they've been fab) and topped off with a pair of Berghaus Deluge Pants which have performed fantastically since I bought them and worn on my walk with Cath and Gareth too.
I brought along a pair of Helly Hansen Lifa long johns for evening wear (!) and my lovely heather Rab Photon Jacket in case the weather was cold (February, Torridon, but actually it was ok!).
On my head I wore a Trekmates Merino Wool Beanie which is super; warm, stretchy, comfortable, and when raining I wore my SealSkinz Cold Weather Hat that really does nothing for me but is warm and waterproof and generally feels ace!
On my feet I wore a pair of Smartwool socks though I have so many pairs I can't remember the specific model, and (horrors) I wore my old lightweight for leather, Brasher Hillwalker GTXs which kept my feet dry and warm though as usual with this particular pair I did start to get hot spots though no actual blisters. I lace them in a particular way to alleviate pressure off my achilles - before I bought these a few years ago I had no idea there were so many ways you could lace up a pair of boots. You Tube it and you will see what I mean!
On my hands I wore a pair of Outdoor Designs Merino StretchOn liners, covered with Trekmates Tromso 3-in-1 Gloves (I don't use the liners that came with them). The OD liners are great. Reasonably priced and keep my hands warm. The Trekmates I'm not sure about yet and think I might prefer mits but will carry on with these til next autumn/winter.

Poles
I have a pair of Leki poles, they must be at least 12 years old. They did have an anti shock system which I'm not sure still works, but which is fine for me as when pitching the Trailstar it helps to have something a little more rigid to use to tension against. (The shock system 'boinging' on the Coldedale Zen walk woke me from my sleep!) But they are incredibly heavy. I really don't want to weigh them! I compared them with some carbon fibre poles Kim showed me, from Gossamer Gear and was staggered. But I don't NEED to change them yet; they've saved me on a few falls now and despite being a little bent they still do the job!

Hygiene
I have an MSR Blizzard Snow Stake after reading the Phil Turner inspired make your own poo stick article from Colin Ibbotson, but without the accoutrements of gross grain ribbon etc. In terrain such as Torridon it was difficult to dig a hole more than 6 inches deep before hitting rock so packing out is a better option. I use a small roll of Andrex On The Go (natch) which is convenient though I'll also use moss or snow if I have to!

I use a normal Oral B toothbrush without having sawn the handle off, with a small 'pot' of Theramed toothpaste which I swallow when brushing my teeth rather than swilling and spitting as I'd do at home. I used babywipes for my face and bod though on my own I usually use my MSR packtowel ('Ultra' I think though I'm not absolutely sure which variety now, there's quite a few) cut in half in conjunction with some water boiled in the kettle and a small tube of face wash / bar of soap (which I find better personally for cleanliness and is okay if stored in a small plastic bag). The towel then gets attached to my pack (in decent weather) to dry as I walk. The packtowel is a great, simple piece of kit that I used to wipe off water from the bag, sleeping pad and anywhere else, and having cut it in two I can separate one for hygiene. When I'm out for more than a couple of days I boil it in my pot to keep it sanitised. I don't know what other people do?

I take a small selection of plasters and compeed with some painkillers too, in a small plastic bag. I have actually used items in my kit; compeed and micropore tape with melolin for blisters on the West Highland Way (the scissors on my classic Victorinox penknife were invaluable in cutting it up), and painkillers when I did my knee in on the Coledale Zen walk in the autumn. I've never needed more but I think with walking alone so much I want to learn more about general stopping blood and fixing up more dire problems for myself if I do ever need it. I know first aid kits have produced a lot of discussion in different blogs; a matter of risk management and I'm risk averse in this case.

Well done if you have got this far! I am running out of steam but have covered most of the points, apart from:
navigation: I took a compass, whistle and mini thermometer combo I have on a lanyard, 65g, a guidebook and OS map with an Ortlieb mapcase (very much needed in the wet). Plus a Tikka Plus Headtorch (the switch seems to be playing up so I shall look at alternatives now) and spare batteries; all items I take on every walk I do.



I am conscious that there will be a few small odds and sods I've not mentioned, coffee, maybe other bits of food for example, but by and large this is what I took. I think it was pretty well equipped and I felt safe and comfortable (apart from that dodgy switch on the torch which I must get sorted). While there is room for improvement, hopefully you will find it interesting / useful / amusing to see what I have!

(A last point; I will spreadsheet the kit and weights at some point for public viewing...!)

34 comments:

  1. Great informative post. Really enjoyed reading it especially as I'm on the same journey, trying to get my kit lighter. I have a couple of questions:

    One I don't really know or have seen a Trailstar in the wild but I take it that it doesn't have the flexability of a tarp when it comes to pitching even although it's just a sheet?

    Why a blow torch and not a fire steel, is this because you were using Esbit tables, again I have never used them? As that would lighten the load.

    Lots for me to go and digest. Has got me thinking about my kit.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Tookie, Thinking is always good! I like how we can bounce ideas around freely and it helps me too.
    A Trailstar does have a fair bit of flexibility and if you look on that link I put in the post there are a few pitching pics at the bottom of the page. It's a 5 sided cat-cut tarp/shelter and like other more basic cat cut tarps you are more limited *in certain ways* though I think you get better all around protection generally speaking. So it isn't just a sheet (you really need to see one) and you can't pitch it in the same way as a normal flat, rectangular tarp.
    A fire steel would not have grabbed the esbit very well; it was pretty wet and windy even with the shelter of the Trailstar. For this trip a gas canister stove would be a better and I kicked myself to some extent when I saw what Kim had brought along!
    Thinking about a firesteel, in a more sheltered environment I would use one but this was pretty open and wild. And maybe I could do with more practise!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Helen, this is a well-thought-out, respectable kit that meets both weight and quality requirements and probably manages to contains items that are not so expensive that the casual backpacker couldn't afford them.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I see now that I have had a look at the Trailstar link. You can get some really good closed sheltering with a standard square tarp but maybe not for 2 people though. I can see that the shape and the placement of the poles is what makes pitching it smaller awkward.

    I see that you need some fire starting lessons. I reckon with some tumble dryer fluff, a wee bit of vaseline and the firesteel spark would grab the Esbit no problem :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. Sam, Thanks for the comment. I guess there will always be things I want to change, but it lets me get out and that's my focus at the moment. And I love to learn from you guys :o)

    Tookie, We need a Trailstar and Tarp session to swap pitch techniques, maybe even some beers (gulp)! I can't wait to get out with the Tarp again!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Wow! Fantastic post! You get the award for singlemost person in my life that sparks off a gear obsession in me :) . (You DID forget to mention the 7 kilo stereo system and ale filled mini-fridge plus generator but maybe we were keeping that to ourselves? ) ~ smooch ~

    ReplyDelete
  7. great, evolving list...I am in that place too.

    I found the extra info about the Trailstar very useful, ours is being made and hopefully here before April and the next trip. I think we'll definitely need a groundsheet for our first time in a tarp in spring downpours.

    how do you find that ME jacket hood? My GF is sorely in need of a new 3 season coat, but trips to the stores the other day were a dead loss. We looked at it but I wasn't sure about whether it would stay on in a breeze. Sizing is still a real problem I think, I wish for her sake clothes companies would get their act together and start making stuff for all sizes, and not just in weird shades of purple either! There was a rather nice hagloffs jacket in her size but at 350£ its not for mere mortals....

    ReplyDelete
  8. Helen, I love your attitude toward gear... that of ACTUALLY USING IT and not putting it foremost in your mind for things to do in the hills. And using things until they wear out. I used to do that... care for each and every item I owned for hiking... until I got into UL and somehow nothing was every enough. A new thing I had hardly even tried out suddenly needed to be replaced by the latest, greatest change in a single strand of string weight. Lately I've been slowly getting rid of stuff and settling down on gear that works and that will last a while. Eventually I hope to go back to my one pack, one shelter, one sleeping bag way of life. But it's so hard getting rid of stuff you spent so much time researching and then acquiring!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Nice one, Helen. Getting out is the main thing, and anyone can do that with the gear they already have. It's not worth waiting to get the superest, bested things available (or unavailable) if you can make do with what you have.

    Your comments on polycyro echo my thoughts. It's good stuff, but when it rips, it keeps on ripping. I tried making a hole in the middle of a sheet for the DuoMid support pole. Big mistake, and I forgot the duct tape. Still, it's cheap I guess.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Cheers Helen, I was one of those who asked about kit. last year was my first on backpacking - normally camp from a canoe where weight is not an issue.

    I am thinking of a Trailstar. Currently use a micro tarp but i choose my weather. Also have a tarp which may have to do for now.

    Thanks again

    ReplyDelete
  11. Excellent post. Although I'm not sure what you're doing to the polycryo. My first bit wouldn't unfold full width so ditched it after a month. Otherwise the 1 bit of polycryo has lasted the TGO last year and every trip since, except 3 nights when I've used Tyvek due to 2 people in the Trailstar. My dad got my Tyvek from somewhere in the UK that sold it by the metre will find the link.

    Its interesting to see how you're stuff has changed and reduced since our first trip to Scotland months ago, but like you said the main thing is just to get out there.

    One day I will post both my multi-day and day pack lists once I've finished testing a few things I'm playing with.

    The H2O review will be up this weekend ;-)

    Oh I need one of those flamethrower lighters for Esbit but I have always eventually managed to light Esbit, matches are easier than a bic lighter.

    This reminds me I once thought about a gear site a bit like gdgt.com but for Outdoors gear..hmm..

    ReplyDelete
  12. I forgot!! It would be excellent if one day a load of us could actually get together and see each others kit. A mini trip/gear fest is the best way to see it. It's one of the reasons I like walking with Phil, not just is company (nothing wrong with that either) ;-)

    ReplyDelete
  13. Steven, Thank you (I think). I haven't ripped the Polycryo yet; it's just a pain and hassle to pack away. Silnylon is just so much easier and i'm strangely more inclined to look after it (probably because it's easier to unpack and pack).
    Thought you wouldn't mind the H2O plug...

    ReplyDelete
  14. I generally tend to steer clear of "gear chat", but I found that post really useful and interesting reading Helen. It's great to see someone with a more realistic approach to gear, i.e. being constrained by budget, time etc, and I think your thoughts are much more relevant to the average backpacker than many I've seen.

    I have a similar attitude in that I'd much rather spend resources on getting to the hills and certainly would rather be "out there" than traipsing around stores (either online or offline). Also I think a lot of people find that they need to make compromises rather than buying a number of items to suit different conditions.

    There are definitely a few items in your kit which look interesting so I'll be following up a few of your links. In particular, your Caldera Cone gets a lot of praise. Although I like a gas stove for its cleanliness and quickness, I don't like the requirement to find recycling facilities for the canisters. Something like the Cone would maybe suit me better in this respect?

    Now I'm going to go and find out what the 5th season is! :D

    ReplyDelete
  15. Great read; its always nice to see other hikers kit lists.

    I'm guessing that you don't use a bivvy bag when tarping.

    This is one area I'm not confident in and find it difficult to move away from a 2-skin tent.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Thanks Nick! Phil Turner described it well on Twitter earlier, with calling me a 'Transitional backpacker'; someone in the middle of that journey to lightweight. I thought it would be useful for people to see in one post what I take as an example. Although it's a long post, seeing everything in one place is useful occasionally; it certainly has been today and even re-reading the post myself I think about different combinations of things.
    I would wholeheartedly recommend the Caldera Cone (in my case specific to the MSR Titan Kettle). Do check out Trail Designs (who make it); they are a friendly couple of guys, passionate about what they do, and I just love the simple design that works so well. It's a piece of kit I think will serve me for a long time to come. If I could and money was no object then I'd get the Sidewinder Inferno version with the titanium 0.9l Evernew pot, letting you burn twigs etc as well as the meths stove and gram cracker, but can't justify it right now.

    George, I'm glad you enjoyed it; it is good to have a nose around isn't it! No, I don't use a bivy under the Trailstar as a rule, but under a normal rectangular or a cat cut Tarp I would, unless the forecast was pretty decent. I would be more included to use a bivy with a down bag too; this Snugpak synthetic bag is probably more robust than I give it credit.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Tap up Colin Ibbotson for one of those half Trailstar floor area ground sheets I got of him. Light and brilliant. Interesting kit list. One stand out bit of kit is the Trailstar. Super shelter. Wind does nothing to it. I have been out in my in horrendous conditions and been fine. One bit of kit that will get used for years.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Wow an excellent post on gear. I have a trailstar and it is an excellent shelter, though I have not experienced strong winds in it. I am moving toward the use of a MLD Speedmid as it more suits my needs in Lapland (yes I am selling my trailstar) I have a Golite SL 1 and see it as my winter shelter it provides ample space for one and with the inner net provides sufficient warmth in temps well below zero C. We use a Black Diamond Betalight when my partner and I go hiking and with a solo inner (for solo use), such as the MLD inner or the Six Moon designs serenity net tent it would provide a comfortable area for sleeping as well as wet gear and cooking.

    I love esbit, in my Trail designs sidewinder I find that Esbit is more efficient than alcohol, to light the esbit I use a mini bic lighter and a few drop of alcohol hand cleaner, works every time and is lighter than a turbo flame lighter.

    Pillows take a look at the Exped Air Pillow, nice shape and works for me.

    I need to look for the Blue Dragon Ramen Noodles, they look like the Rice Noodle pack found in Dk. Certainly the Blue Dragon food has a lot of potential for backpacking, sadly the variety is better in Sweden than it is in Denmark.

    Black Diamond head torches are very good, I have the original Ion (circa 2006) the new ones seem to be equally as good. (see http://www.needlesports.com/Catalogue/Lighting/Micro-Head-Torches/Ion-BDI-STAR )

    Thanks once again for an informative and detailed post, enjoy the pursuit for the holy grail of hiking gear.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Great Helen! Sounds like you are heading the right way as far as weight. The packs look interesting. The weight of the pack is something i had never thought about until recently but i see it is an area to reduce a great deal of weight. The trailstar looks interesting but just not sure about that style of shelter. I love being enclosed in a traditional style tent. I have been looking at a shangri-la 3 recently as like teepee stlye and have seen you can get inner tents for it.

    Keep up the great work.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I forget to say; get a Naglene type bottle, one with a wide mouth.

    Makes filling up from streams so much easier, Lidl or Aldi sometimes have their own make selling for a quid.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I like your post. It is interesting, well written and brings back memories of being so cold at Reaps Moor in January in a Snugpack Softie Kestrel 3 that I had to wear waterproofs inside the sleeping bag. At least Glen van Peski would have approved. If you used a high quality, ultralight down bag, you would have to put it inside a bivy bag and that's going to add 200g or more (plus some warmth).

    It is worth adding a handle on that big tent peg. Definitely more comfortable, so the digging gets easier. I was given some stretchy tape which sticks to itself by some very kind people on Orkney. In October, I used it to fasten a bit of closed cell foam to the peg and the tape is still holding the foam in place. You don't have to go to Orkney to get it because the tape came from a pound shop. Sadly, I cannot tell you the brand name because I have not retained the packaging.

    I agree with Tookie about lighting Esbit. There are quite a few products with petroleum gel dissolved into a substrate and they will light Esbit after themselves being lit by a spark. I use Hammaro paper, which came from Bob and Rose. It is very cheap, considering how little it takes to get a fire going and will last years if kept in a plastic bag. Of course, I could use a Bic, but where is the fun in that? Actually, the last time I relied on a lighter, it emptied itself of gas inside my rucksack. That was two decades ago and I haven't used one since.

    Snap with the stinky polycryo. That stuff needs scrupulous drying out.

    The Trailstar is a big, old beast and obtrusively pale. I'm not sure I'll ever like mine as much as my Cave. Water has come through its seams so they will have to be sealed, which has never been necessary with previous tarps and flysheets. Big stitch holes? Also, for those who wonder why you didn't re-pitch the Trailstar when stuff came in, I find that air rushing past the gaps below the panels creates a low pressure area and this draws air in through the door. The airflow through my Trailstar isn't dramatic but makes candle use difficult.

    Some years ago I treated myself to a sea kayak. The handling was a disappointment. Then she told me her name, Sunneshine. This is something to do with an explorer who did big things in 1585 up near the home of the sea kayak and was apt, given her golden deck. We have never become best friends but we have had some great paddles since the naming. Unfortunately, the Trailstar told me its name is White Elephant. Perhaps that will change at Easter. I haven't given up on it yet, not least because I can confirm Martin's comment on its ability to deal with wind.

    ReplyDelete
  22. George, Thanks for the Nalgene comment! I don't use mine so much now but maybe something I'll think about...

    Zed, I really appreciate your putting so much thought into your comment and sharing it here (and making me smile!). Lots for me to think about; it's nice to get details as it's often the nuances that I pick up on in 'real life' and blogs aren't so good for that generally.
    Not sure about the Trailstar being a White Elephant for me. I think I will enjoy it in the Spring - Autumn more, but we each have to find what works for ourselves. My biggest issue with it is that it is so big! I could have repitched it but I honestly don't think it would have made that much difference though I hadn't considered the air pressure differential - interesting!
    Sea kayaks are a great dream; but that is way into the future for me I think but sounds like a lot of fun and a different way to immerse myself (probably literally) in the landscape :o)

    ReplyDelete
  23. Helen, great post. I like to wear out kit too. My original Jam still has 100's of miles left in it. Also the use of a pillow. I got one on a whim and it's changed the way I sleep. After fiddling with all sorts of sleep mats and never getting it quite right I now use the pillow and 12mm CCF mat and sleep brilliantly. Pillows rule!

    ReplyDelete
  24. Helen, great post and has got me thinking lots about my own gear. I think I am even further back towards the average backpacker in terms of weight, but having experimented with different tents and binning everything I don't need from my pack, I'm starting to change as well. Sleeping bag and mat have been reduced to a neo air and a Rab quantum 400, but it's my fondness for a tent that currently is causing me problems. I'm tempted by the Nemo GoGo as a halfway house between a Bivi and a tent with a weight of around 1kg and they have the Obi 1 at 900g if I really fancied a tent, but they are a serious investment, even at trade prices! I know if I went for a tarp I would make even more savings in weight but for me, I'm just a little nervous about having something so open to the elements, but I can imagine the feeling of being that much closer to your environment being a plus as well.

    Rucksack wise, I have never tried anything as light as the Golite and I worry about comfort, I've tried the Zepton 50 from Lowe and the Z55 from Gregory although my preference is for the Zepton. Cooking I'm on a MSR kettle and Coleman f1 but having seen your Caldera, I'm seriously intrigued! Sadly Trail Designs do not have a UK distributor and having been burnt with a direct deal in the past with a non-UK brand we sadly couldn't go any further with Randy and crew.

    Clothing wise, I swear by the Marmot Mica Jacket (198g) and essence trousers (174g) They have shaved loads of my previous waterproof / windproof combination. On a seperate note, Book of the Bivy has had me in stitches and is coming closer to persuade me to head out with a tarp or bivvy!

    ReplyDelete
  25. John, Thanks! I may have a chat with you about how you carry your mat on the Jam ,which one you use etc.

    G, Looks like you've made a great start; binning anything extraneous is the way to go! Tents and shelters are a big issue and I saw those models on the Webtogs site too. Interesting approach. Sometimes it helps to borrow or just try on a pack if you're walking with someone else; I've learned a lot this way.
    And so glad you enjoyed the Book of the Bivvy, that's put a smile on my face!

    Thanks Janine! If I had the cash (or credit card) to spare then I'd have a different winter set up too. But the important thing is to not get too hung up on gear and get out there!

    ReplyDelete
  26. Great Helen! Sounds like you are heading the right way as far as weight. The packs look interesting. The weight of the pack is something i had never thought about until recently but i see it is an area to reduce a great deal of weight. The trailstar looks interesting but just not sure about that style of shelter. I love being enclosed in a traditional style tent. I have been looking at a shangri-la 3 recently as like teepee stlye and have seen you can get inner tents for it.

    Keep up the great work.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Great informative post. Really enjoyed reading it especially as I'm on the same journey, trying to get my kit lighter. I have a couple of questions:

    One I don't really know or have seen a Trailstar in the wild but I take it that it doesn't have the flexability of a tarp when it comes to pitching even although it's just a sheet?

    Why a blow torch and not a fire steel, is this because you were using Esbit tables, again I have never used them? As that would lighten the load.

    Lots for me to go and digest. Has got me thinking about my kit.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Thanks Martin! Do it! It's fun, pretty much free once you've got the kit and it's probably THE best way to feel connected to the world around you :o)

    ReplyDelete
  29. Already got most of the kit (assuming it hasn't perished due to lack of use?!). Not as lightweight as some of today's options, but then again, neither am I ;)

    I've even got an old military poncho somewhere. Never considered "tarping" in a non tactical sense. Worth a thought...

    ReplyDelete
  30. Great blog,great post! Sounds like you had fun!
    I have just ordered a Trailstar , it seems to be the shelter of the moment.
    What drew me to it was the ease with which it goes up and the fact that it is "bombproof"!
    I am doing the WHW this summer and would love to take the Trailstar, but it would have to have a bug shelter for me to do that! Do you know if any members of the Trailstar 'club' have found anything that fits, I'd make one but can't sew!!

    ReplyDelete
  31. Hi! Thanks for your comment :o)
    For bug nets I've come across the Bear Paw Wilderness Designs Penta Net 2 http://www.bearpawwd.com/shelters_floors/pentaNet2.html, and Six Moon Designs Serenity Net Tent, http://bit.ly/g0G2JG so far. I've not tried either so can't recommend as such, but yes, you would certainly need a midge net in Scotland in Summer unless you were completely hardcore / a little bit nuts!
    Best of luck on your walk though!

    ReplyDelete
  32. And there's a great thread on BPL's site:
    http://www.backpackinglight.com/cgi-bin/backpackinglight/forums/thread_display.html?forum_thread_id=40756&skip_to_post=380229

    ReplyDelete
  33. A great read.
    I seem to have linked this thread to an old blog I have, no idea how what or why I did, all I can say is ops.
    One day I will look into it more. Bit beyond me.
    The little green one much easier.
    T.

    ReplyDelete
  34. A great read.
    I seem to have linked this thread to an old blog I have, no idea how what or why I did, all I can say is ops.
    One day I will look into it more. Bit beyond me.
    The little green one much easier.
    T.

    ReplyDelete